🧑‍🚒Liability to Landlord Insurance Is Not Negotiable

Our leases have always required tenants to carry liability to landlord coverage. But a requirement on paper only works if someone checks.

In May, our software turned on enforcement. Every tenant without proof of a policy got five days to upload one or be automatically enrolled.

On October 12, that coverage paid for a fire.

🔥 What happened

On Monday night, October 12, a candle left burning in a bedroom started a fire in one of our rentals. Everyone got out. The fire department closed the unit: major smoke damage, some water damage, and one bedroom badly burned.

The tenant had canceled her renters insurance in 2024. Her only coverage was the liability to landlord coverage our lease requires.

🧯 What would have happened without it

If renters insurance were our only requirement, there would have been nothing. No policy, no coverage, and an owner looking at a burned unit with nobody to collect from.

Instead, every lease requires at least $100,000 in liability to landlord coverage. Tenants who show us their own policy keep it. Tenants who don't are enrolled in ours. Because we hold the program, we were the ones who could open the claim.

That one requirement is why this is a repair project and not a collections case.

🏚️ What it paid for

Because the tenant caused the fire, the liability to landlord coverage was primary. On October 16, the adjuster walked the unit and approved clearing the basement and starting the tear-out. The coverage pays for the building, which is exactly what the owner needed.

Once cleanup and demo are finished, the rebuild goes to our maintenance team. It should mainly be drywall, paint, and flooring.

🚫 What it didn't pay for

Liability to landlord coverage is not renters insurance, and this claim showed exactly where the line is.

It did not cover:

1. Her belongings. Most of what was in the burned bedroom couldn't be saved.
2. A hotel or any living expenses.
3. The pack-out. On October 19, the carrier put it in writing: "We do not cover for pack-out."

That's how it's supposed to work. Renters insurance covers personal property, the tenant's own liability, and loss of use when the home isn't livable. Liability to landlord coverage protects the building, not the tenant's things.

🔁 Everyone thought it was renters insurance

Over the next week, the owner and the restoration contractor each asked whether the renters insurance would pay for the pack-out. I explained it to the carrier, then the owner, then the contractor: there was no renters policy, the coverage we had pays for the building, and the contents were the tenant's responsibility.

The confusion makes sense. When people hear "the tenant has insurance," they assume it covers the tenant's belongings. This policy has "landlord" in the name for a reason: it protects the landlord's building, not the tenant's things.

🙋‍♀️ What we got right

We had the claim open the afternoon after the fire, even though the carrier's website only offered a callback form and the first number we found was a sales line. Four days after the fire, the adjuster was walking the unit and had approved the tear-out.

We kept one message for everyone. The carrier, the owner, and the contractor each got the same explanation of what the coverage did and didn't pay for, so nobody worked from a different version.

We also sent every rent question to one person. Leasing didn't discuss rent with the tenant, so nobody made a promise we'd have to take back.

📋 What you can steal

1. Turn enforcement on. Proof of a policy or automatic enrollment, every lease, every tenant. Five days is plenty.
2. Set a minimum. Ours is $100,000 in liability to landlord coverage.
3. Look at personal property add-ons. Some programs now offer optional contents coverage in the $5,000 to $10,000 range. That's the gap that hurt this household.
4. Say in one sentence what it doesn't cover. Put it in the move-in packet: "This pays for damage to the building. It does not pay for your belongings, a hotel, or moving your things. That's what renters insurance is for." Include Wisconsin's plain-language guide to renters insurance so tenants know what to buy.
5. Check coverage at renewal, not just at move-in. Our tenant had renters insurance once. A VA can run this check every month.
6. Save the claims number, not the sales number. Put it in your emergency procedure and call it once now so you know it works.
7. Give on-call staff a fire-night script. No promises about housing, rent, timelines, or fault.
8. Send candle rules before winter break. December is the peak month for home candle fires, and more than a third start in the bedroom. Attach NFPA's candle safety tip sheet to your "leaving for break" notice.

✅ This week

Open your insurance coverage report and find every tenant with neither their own policy on file nor enrollment in yours. Each one is an uncovered fire. Fix that before the next candle.

📚 Worth a read:

💳 Your Delinquency Problem Has a Fix. We Already Did the Vetting.

Here's a scenario you know well. A resident pays on the 11th instead of the 1st, most months. You post the notice, send the text, your team eats the hours. And the frustrating part is that it usually isn't about money or character — there's just nothing linking

PM Monthly ForecastRegine Collins

🐾 We Picked a Pet Screening Partner. Here's the Question That Decided It.

Back in June I told you we run every applicant through a pet vetting platform, and that assistance animal verification is the part that used to keep me up at night. I also told you to build your accommodation workflow with your attorney, because that's the step that saves

PM Monthly ForecastRegine Collins

🦠 "There's Black Mold in My Apartment" — What That Work Order Actually Means

A tenant submits a work order at 11:40 on a Saturday night. Photo attached: a shower curtain with dark speckling along the bottom hem. Subject line: BLACK MOLD. The bathroom has a working exhaust fan. You know that because you replaced it fourteen months ago, and because somebody on

PM Monthly ForecastRegine Collins